The Housewives of Mannheim
by Alan Brody
In 1944 Brooklyn, a beautiful housewife's innocent visit to see a Vermeer painting at the Metropolitan Museum sets off a chain of personal awakenings that forces her to confront hidden desires, challenge social conventions, and choose between the safety of conformity and the dangerous freedom of authentic self-discovery.
_________
THE HOUSEWIVES OF MANNHEIM is set in a Brooklyn apartment building in 1944, where three women navigate friendship, sexuality, and self-discovery while their husbands fight overseas. The play takes its title from a fictional Vermeer painting that becomes a metaphor for how women are seen and how they see themselves across time.
Act I introduces May Black, a beautiful housewife who lives with her 10-year-old son Bobby while her husband Lenny serves in the war. Her best friend is Billie Friedhoff, a sharp-tongued, sexually liberated woman trapped in a loveless marriage to a dentist. Their neighbor Alice Cohen represents conventional domesticity, obsessed with contests, rationing, and maintaining respectability.
The catalyst arrives when Sophie Birnbaum, an elegant European refugee in her 60s, moves into the building. Sophie is a former concert pianist who fled Nazi-occupied Paris after her non-Jewish husband died. May is immediately drawn to Sophie's sophistication and worldliness.
After hearing about "The Housewives of Mannheim" on the radio, May impulsively visits the Metropolitan Museum - her first independent cultural expedition. This sparks an intellectual awakening. She begins reading art books, applies secretly to Brooklyn College, and finds herself questioning everything about her prescribed role as wife and mother.
Sophie becomes May's mentor, teaching her about art, music, and seeing the world with fresh eyes. Meanwhile, Billie, who has harbored romantic feelings for May for ten years, grows jealous of this new friendship. The act culminates at a bohemian party where Billie finally acts on her feelings, seducing May in a moment of vulnerability and alcohol-fueled intimacy.
Act II deals with the fallout. May is horrified by what happened and retreats into denial and self-loathing. When she discovers that Sophie has also had relationships with women, May feels betrayed and manipulated. In a devastating scene, she accidentally breaks Sophie's rare recordings - the only remaining copies of her pre-war concerts - then watches helplessly as Sophie destroys the rest rather than leave them for someone who will reject both the music and the musician.
May seeks refuge in conventional morality, turning to Alice and rejecting both women. She spreads word about Billie throughout the building, destroying her friend's linen business and social standing. She abandons her college applications and vows to return to being a "normal" housewife when Lenny comes home.
The climax forces all three women to confront the truth about love, friendship, and authenticity. Sophie, drawing on her experience of how hatred spreads when people choose willful ignorance, warns May that denying what she's learned will lead to a life of dangerous silence and eventual persecution of others. Billie demands honesty about their relationship, refusing to let May hide behind the fiction that she was merely a victim.
The play concludes with a moment of tentative reconciliation and growth. May begins to acknowledge the complexity of her feelings and the value of what she's learned from both women. As she prepares coffee for all three friends (Alice included), they freeze in the exact positions of the Vermeer painting - suggesting that women across time have always grappled with similar questions of identity, desire, and the courage to live authentically.
Themes: The play explores sexual awakening and female desire, the tension between conformity and self-discovery, friendship as a catalyst for growth, and the danger of choosing ignorance over difficult truths. It's ultimately about the courage required to live an examined life and the price of both conformity and authenticity.